Which soil mix should I use?
Every Lucy's Soil mix, sorted by the job it does. Find the question that matches what you are growing, and the answer names the mix and what sets it apart from its neighbors. Every mix page lists every ingredient.
Rather answer two quick questions? The mix finder on our homepage does the sorting for you. To see every pro mix side by side, use the Pro Mixes page.
Which mix for starting seeds in plug trays and flats?
Classic: #1 Classic All-Purpose Germination Mix has been our germination workhorse since 1985. It carries a phosphorus-heavy 10-50-10 starter charge, micronutrients and a wetting agent, and suits annuals, perennials and vegetables in plug trays and inserts. #1A Classic Plug Tray Germination Mix is the same base with fine perlite added, for production plug trays and automated seeders where even moisture across the tray matters most.
Organic: #10 Organic Germination Mix with Compost adds compost and an organic nutrient charge, with Suståne MycoBio, and was developed with the organic vegetable grower in mind. #12 Organic Germination Mix, No Compost leaves out the compost and adds kelp meal, recommended as-is for micro-greens and delicate lettuce or for growers who add their own compost. #10X Organic Germination Mix, Reduced Peat skips vermiculite and perlite entirely and uses HydraFiber for air and moisture.
The germination mixes side by side:
#10 Organic Germination Mix with Compost
- Blend
- Organic
- Base
- Sphagnum peat moss
- Compost
- Yes
- Vermiculite or perlite
- Both
- Best for
- Organic vegetable starts
- Sets it apart
- Compost for added humic acid
#10X Organic Germination Mix, Reduced Peat
- Blend
- Organic
- Base
- HydraFiber
- Compost
- Yes
- Vermiculite or perlite
- Neither
- Best for
- Seed starting
- Sets it apart
- HydraFiber for air and moisture
#12 Organic Germination Mix, No Compost
- Blend
- Organic
- Base
- Sphagnum peat moss
- Compost
- No
- Vermiculite or perlite
- Both
- Best for
- Micro-greens
- Sets it apart
- No compost, so you can add your own
#1 Classic All-Purpose Germination Mix
- Blend
- Classic
- Base
- Sphagnum peat moss
- Compost
- No
- Vermiculite or perlite
- Vermiculite
- Best for
- Plug trays and inserts
- Sets it apart
- Phosphorus-heavy 10-50-10 starter charge
Which mix for soil blocks?
#C3 Organic Soil-Blocking Germination Mix. Soil blocking replaces plastic trays: a hand tool compresses the mix into blocks, which are seeded with their sides and bottoms open to the air. #C3 holds its shape in the blocker, and the open sides air-prune the roots so seedlings branch instead of circling a cell. It carries an organic nutrient charge.
Market gardeners and growers moving away from plastic trays are its regular users; Wild Woods Farm starts its transplants in it. No Lucy's Soil mix is certified organic or OMRI Listed. Certified growers can ask for our certification packet, with the documents your inspector needs. Read more about the method on the #C3 page.
Which mix for growing on in pots and containers?
Neutral: #2 Neutral All-Purpose Growing Mix is a peat-based mix with no fertilizer added, so you set the feed program. It is the usual choice for growers who fertigate or mix in their own fertilizer. It includes a wetting agent.
Organic: #11 Organic Growing Mix with Compost adds compost for humic acid and is the pick for vegetable transplants. #13 Organic Growing Mix, No Compost leaves out the compost and adds kelp meal, for micro-greens, delicate lettuce or growers who add their own. #11X Organic Growing Mix, Reduced Peat drops vermiculite and perlite and uses HydraFiber and compost instead. All three include Suståne MycoBio.
The growing mixes side by side:
#11 Organic Growing Mix with Compost
- Blend
- Organic
- Base
- Sphagnum peat moss
- Compost
- Yes
- Vermiculite or perlite
- Both
- Best for
- Vegetable transplants
- Sets it apart
- Compost for added humic acid
#11X Organic Growing Mix, Reduced Peat
- Blend
- Organic
- Base
- HydraFiber
- Compost
- Yes
- Vermiculite or perlite
- Neither
- Best for
- Annuals, perennials, vegetables and flowers
- Sets it apart
- HydraFiber for air and moisture
#13 Organic Growing Mix, No Compost
- Blend
- Organic
- Base
- Sphagnum peat moss
- Compost
- No
- Vermiculite or perlite
- Both
- Best for
- Micro-greens
- Sets it apart
- No compost, so you can add your own
#2 Neutral All-Purpose Growing Mix
- Blend
- Neutral
- Base
- Sphagnum peat moss
- Compost
- No
- Vermiculite or perlite
- Both
- Best for
- Fertigation
- Sets it apart
- No fertilizer added
Which mix for hanging baskets, perennials, mums and shrubs?
#4 All-Purpose Bark Based Growing Mix is our bark-based growing mix and the usual choice for hanging baskets. Bark gives it higher porosity than a peat mix, so it fills the edges of the pot even when dry instead of pulling away. It carries a calcium nitrate charge and suits annuals, perennials and vegetables too.
#5 High-Porosity Bark Based Growing Mix is lighter still, with more porosity than #4 and no vermiculite. Growers use it for mums, perennial grasses, shrubs and trees that prefer to stay moist, so it fits lowland perennials better than upland ones. Suståne MycoBio can be added to either bark mix for added root enhancement.
Which mixes are organic, and what does that mean here?
These mixes are blended for organic growing: #10, #12 and #10X for germination, #11, #13 and #11X for growing on, and #C3 for soil blocks. Instead of a 10-50-10 charge they feed with bone meal, soy meal or soy flour, kelp meal, sulfate of potash, soft rock phosphate and Suståne MycoBio.
No Lucy's Soil mix is certified organic or OMRI Listed. Certified growers can ask for our certification packet, with the documents your inspector needs. The organic mixes page compares them all, and What's In It explains each ingredient.
Which mixes cut peat and mined aggregates?
#10X Organic Germination Mix, Reduced Peat and #11X Organic Growing Mix, Reduced Peat. Both leave out vermiculite and perlite, the mined aggregates in most mixes, and use HydraFiber for air space and moisture, with compost for conductivity. They are made for growers who want to use less peat and fewer mined inputs without changing how they grow.
#10X is the germination version for plug trays and flats. #11X is the growing-on version for pots. Both are organic blends with the organic nutrient package described above.
With compost or without?
Compost adds humic acid, slow-release nutrients and soil life. Leave it out for micro-greens and delicate lettuce, or if you add your own.
Classic, neutral or organic?
Classic germination mixes, #1 and #1A, carry a 10-50-10 starter fertilizer and a micronutrient package. Neutral #2 has no fertilizer, so you can add your own. The bark mixes, #4 and #5, are specialty mixes with a calcium nitrate charge. Organic mixes feed with bone meal, soy, kelp, potash, phosphate and Suståne MycoBio instead. Pick by how you feed, not by label.
Which bag for a home garden?
All Purpose Potting Mix comes in 20 and 40 quart bags for houseplants, tropicals, annuals, perennials and containers. Its base is hypnum peat, which holds moisture so well that no wetting agent is needed.
Professional Grade Raised Bed Mix comes in 1.5 cubic foot bags for raised beds and large containers. It is heavy on compost and hypnum peat, includes mycorrhizae, and is made for multi-year use: add more each season instead of replacing it.
The Soil Calculator tells you how many bags to buy, and Where to Buy lists the stores that stock them. More on both bags on For Home Gardeners.
Still deciding between two mixes?
Ask for a sample. Growers can request a sample bag of any mix and run a tray or two before ordering a pallet. Then call us and tell us what you are growing and how you water and feed; we have helped Midwest growers pick a mix since 1985. Our FAQ covers sizes, ordering and pickup.
Ready to order?
Tell us which mix and how much, and we will quote it.
Request a quote or call 319-500-3505